When a materials science postdoc at a North American university first synthesized CdSe quantum dots in the early 2000s, the critical reagent was not the cadmium salt or the selenium precursor — it was trioctylphosphine. The synthesis, borrowed from the group at MIT that had published the landmark 1993 procedure, called for dissolving selenium powder in trioctylphosphine to form a clear, pale yellow solution of tri-n-octylphosphine selenide, which was then injected rapidly into hot coordinating solvent to nucleate the nanocrystals. The postdoc spent three attempts getting no particles at all before a senior labmate pointed out the problem: she had used a bottle of TOP from a general reagent supplier whose product turned out to be a roughly 70 percent mixture, the rest being dioctylphosphine and other phosphine oxides from incomplete alkylation. Switching to 90 percent purity material gave nucleation on the first injection. The lesson passed down through that group, and eventually through half the nanomaterials community, was that TOP purity is not a minor specification detail — it is the reaction variable.